DTG vs Screen Printing for Custom T-Shirts
Choosing the wrong print method on a 10-shirt run can cost you an extra £80 before you ever hold the finished garments.
What Is DTG Printing?
Direct-to-garment (DTG) printing uses a modified inkjet head to spray water-based ink straight onto the fabric. No screens, no stencils. The machine handles unlimited colours in a single pass, which means photographs, gradients, and fine detail all reproduce faithfully.
Setup cost: zero. A single shirt typically costs £12–£18 to print, but you can order just one. It works best on 100% cotton or cotton-heavy blends. The Gildan Heavy Cotton T-Shirt is a go-to blank across the UK printing industry precisely because its tight weave holds DTG ink without bleed or spreading.
One cost to factor in: printing on dark fabric requires a white underbase layer. That adds £2–£4 per shirt and can leave a faint border at the print edge if the pre-treatment is uneven.
What Is Screen Printing?
Screen printing forces ink through a mesh stencil stretched over a frame. Each colour needs its own screen, and each screen costs £15–£25 to prepare. On a 6-shirt run, that setup fee can triple the unit price. At 48+ shirts, the same cost spreads thin enough that you can print below £4 per shirt.
The results are vibrant and opaque, especially on dark fabrics where DTG struggles most. Plastisol inks sit proud of the weave rather than soaking in, which gives the print a clean, raised feel. A plain chest logo in two colours on a Fruit of the Loom Classic Hooded Sweatshirt is one of the most cost-effective custom prints available once quantities reach 24+.
Cost at a Glance
| Factor | DTG | Screen Printing |
|---|---|---|
| Setup cost | None | £15–£25 per colour |
| Minimum order | 1 unit | Typically 12–24 units |
| Colour limit | Unlimited | Best at 1–4 colours |
| Cost sweet spot | 1–20 shirts | 24+ shirts |
| Photo / gradient support | Excellent | Poor |
| Durability (washes) | Good (50+ washes) | Very good (70+ washes) |
| Dark fabric performance | Requires underbase | Excellent |
Which Should You Choose?
DTG makes sense below 20 units whenever the design contains more than 4 colours or includes a photograph. Screen printing pays off above 30 identical shirts with a simple logo or text. For a streetwear drop, that usually means screen printing the main production run while using DTG for the sample proof.
A mid-weight hoodie blank like the AWDis College Hoodie works well with either method. Its cotton-rich fabric takes DTG ink cleanly at small quantities, and its flat chest panel is ideal for screen printing at scale.
If your design changes between orders, DTG wins outright. Screen printing locks you into the original stencil.
FAQ
Which print method lasts longer, DTG or screen printing?
Screen printing generally outlasts DTG when cared for correctly. Plastisol inks sit on top of the weave and can survive 70+ washes before fading. DTG inks bond into the fibres and hold well past 50 washes, but are more prone to cracking if machine-dried on a high heat setting.
Can I print a photograph onto a custom t-shirt?
Yes, but only with DTG. Screen printing cannot reproduce photographic gradients cost-effectively because each tone requires a separate screen. DTG handles full-colour photos at resolutions up to 1440 dpi, so portrait-quality printing on a cotton tee is straightforward.
What is the minimum order for screen printing in the UK?
Most UK printers set a minimum of 12–24 units per design per colour. Below 12 units, the setup cost per shirt makes screen printing more expensive than DTG for almost every design. Some printers will accept lower quantities but add a short-run surcharge of £20–£40.
Which method works best on black or dark fabric?
Screen printing excels on dark fabric because plastisol inks are fully opaque with no extra cost or process step. DTG on dark garments requires a white underbase layer, which adds time and £2–£4 per unit, and can occasionally show a slight edge at the print boundary.
How long does a DTG order take to produce?
A typical DTG order of 10–20 shirts takes 3–5 working days in production, plus shipping. Rush 24-hour turnaround is available from some printers for a fee. Screen printing usually takes 7–10 working days because screen preparation and curing add steps that cannot be rushed without affecting print quality.