TMK Tees

DTG vs Screen Printing for Custom T-Shirts

DTG vs Screen Printing for Custom T-Shirts — key points at a glance
DTG vs Screen Printing for Custom T-Shirts — key points at a glance
By The TMK Tees Team •

Every print shop has a favourite method, and they'll tell you it's the right one regardless of your order. The truth is simpler than that.

For custom t-shirts under 24 pieces, DTG (direct-to-garment) printing costs less per unit and handles full-colour or photographic artwork without setup fees. For 50 or more identical shirts in one to three colours, screen printing wins on price by a clear margin.

How DTG Printing Works

A DTG machine operates like a wide-format inkjet printer, except the substrate is fabric. Water-based inks fire directly into the fibres. No screens to burn, no per-colour charges. You can print one shirt or fifty and the per-unit cost shifts only slightly below roughly 12 units.

Fabric choice matters enormously here. DTG bonds best with 100% ring-spun cotton. On 50/50 poly-cotton blends, colours print visibly duller because polyester fibres resist water-based inks. If you are sourcing your own blanks, a shirt like the Gildan Heavy Cotton T-Shirt is a reliable starting point: pure cotton, pre-shrunk, consistent weight across a full size run.

How Screen Printing Works

Screen printing burns your design onto a mesh stencil, one screen per colour. Ink pushes through the open mesh onto the garment. Setup costs in UK studios typically run £15 to £25 per colour. Print 12 shirts or 500, that fixed fee stays the same. At 50 pieces, it becomes the cheapest option per unit. At 12 pieces, you are mostly paying for screens.

The method handles solid blocks and bold graphics brilliantly. Gradients and photographic prints require halftone processing, which adds cost and reduces tonal accuracy. One or two colours with clean linework: screen printing is hard to beat on volume.

Cost by Order Size

Order size DTG (approx.) Screen print (approx.)
1 to 12 shirts £9 to £15 per unit £25+ (setup dominates)
12 to 24 shirts £7 to £10 per unit £10 to £14 per unit
50+ shirts £6 to £8 per unit £3 to £6 per unit

Estimates based on a single-sided, two-colour design at a UK studio. Your quote will vary by supplier and garment.

Streetwear and Hoodies

For heavyweight streetwear, screen printing is the industry standard. Thick plastisol inks produce a raised, tactile finish that DTG cannot replicate. Drops with bold chest graphics belong on a screen press. The Gildan Heavy Blend Hoodie is one of the most-printed blanks in UK streetwear for good reason: its weight and cotton-poly ratio take plastisol ink consistently across a full colour run.

DTG on hoodies is possible but uncommon. Most DTG platens are calibrated for flat-lay t-shirts. A hooded bulk garment is awkward to feed, and results vary noticeably between studios. For budget team or sports kits where per-unit cost matters most, a fleece blank like the Fruit of the Loom Classic Sweatshirt keeps the invoice manageable on a screen print order of 36 or more.

The Verdict

One or two pieces with photographic artwork: DTG. A 20-shirt band run in a single colour: screen printing is close. A 72-piece uniform order in fixed brand colours: screen printing, no competition. The UK break-even sits around 24 to 30 units for most two-colour designs. Know your quantity before you contact a printer and you will avoid paying for the wrong method.

Affiliate disclosure: some links in this article are affiliate links. TMK Tees earns a small commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you.

FAQ

Does DTG printing last as long as screen printing?

Both methods are durable with correct care. DTG prints can crack sooner if washed at high temperatures or tumble-dried on a hot setting. Turn the garment inside out, wash at 30 degrees Celsius, and a DTG print should hold for 40 to 50 washes without visible fading.

What is the minimum order for screen printing in the UK?

Most UK studios require 12 to 25 units per design. Below that, some will print smaller quantities but raise the per-unit price to recover screen costs. Under 12 units, DTG is almost always the cheaper route unless the design is a single solid colour with no gradients.

Can screen printing go on dark-coloured shirts?

Yes. Printers lay down a white under-base first, then print colours on top. This adds one extra screen and one print pass per colour, increasing cost slightly. DTG handles dark garments via a chemical pre-treatment applied before printing; the process is automated and already priced into the per-unit rate.

Can I mix sizes in a single DTG order?

In most cases, yes, with no extra charge. Because DTG has no per-screen setup, size mixing is free. You pay per garment. Screen printers may add a fee for size mixing because it disrupts the flow on a printing carousel, so always ask before ordering.

Is embroidery worth considering instead of printing for logos?

For chest logos and cap branding, embroidery is a practical alternative. It does not fade, gives a premium texture, and works on any fabric weight. The one-off digitising fee runs £15 to £30, then each embroidered piece costs roughly £3 to £8 depending on stitch count. Worth it at 50 or more units.

Privacy · Terms · Cookies · Affiliate disclosure